Best value this month
Claude
At everyday quality, every dollar on a Claude plan finishes 24.1 tasks a month, 1.32× ChatGPT. Run Opus 5.5 at medium. Pick the tier by how much you use, because no tier is cheaper per task than another.
Mostly chat, some code$20
Claude Pro
Sonnet 5.5 · medium
1,590 tasks/mo
1.20× ChatGPT Plus (Sol 6.1 low)
Agent coding most days$100
Claude Max
Opus 5.5 · medium
2,341 tasks/mo
1.32× ChatGPT Pro 100 (Sol 6.1 high)
If OpenAI's announced 2× is real: ChatGPT Pro 100 3,537. Not metered yet.
Agent coding all day$200
Claude Ultra
Opus 5.5 · medium
4,784 tasks/mo
1.35× ChatGPT Pro 200 (Sol 6.1 high)
If OpenAI's announced 2× is real: ChatGPT Pro 200 7,074. Not metered yet.
Hardest problems, top quality$200
Claude Ultra
Opus 5.5 · xhigh
1,939 tasks/mo
4.23× ChatGPT Pro 200 (Astra max)
API dollars are not work done
Each lab prices its own tokens. Divide by what a finished task costs and the gap changes size.
The effort dial moves more than the brand
Tasks a month on the $200 plans as you turn effort up. Hover a point for score and cost per task.
Every tier
Tasks counted at everyday agent coding quality (Artificial Analysis index ≥ 48.2) with the best model each plan includes. Faded rows have no meter reading.
Claude Anthropic
| Tier | Price/mo | API value/mo | Tokens/mo | Tasks/mo at everyday agent coding | Tasks per $ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude Pro5-hour and weekly limits | $20 | $1,181Opus 5.5 | 2.9B | 482Opus 5.5 medium | 24.1 |
| Claude Maxwas Claude Max 5x5-hour and weekly limits; Fable up to half the weekly limit | $100 | $5,739Opus 5.5 | 14.0B | 2,341Opus 5.5 medium | 23.4 |
| Claude Ultrawas Claude Max 20xWeekly limit only (no 5-hour limit for verified accounts); Fable up to half the weekly limit | $200 | $11,726Opus 5.5 | 28.6B | 4,784Opus 5.5 medium | 23.9 |
ChatGPT OpenAI
| Tier | Price/mo | API value/mo | Tokens/mo | Tasks/mo at everyday agent coding | Tasks per $ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT GoLimited Codex access | $8 | No published meter reading · no included model reaches index 48.2Includes Luna | |||
| ChatGPT Plus5-hour and weekly limits | $20 | $213Sol 6.1 | 1.0B | 361Sol 6.1 high | 18.0 |
| ChatGPT Pro 1002× announced 10-29, unmeteredWeekly limit only | $100 | $1,045Sol 6.1 | 5.1B | 1,769Sol 6.1 high | 17.7 |
| ChatGPT Pro 2002× announced 10-29, unmeteredWeekly limit only | $200 | $2,090Sol 6.1 | 10.2B | 3,537Sol 6.1 high | 17.7 |
| ChatGPT Pro 5002× announced 10-29, unmeteredWeekly limit only; Ultrafast mode | $500 | $5,390Sol 6.1 | 26.3B | 9,120Sol 6.1 high | 18.2 |
Google AI Google
Unmeasured. Nobody has published a usage-meter reading for these plans, so their capacity cannot be ranked. Tiers are listed with the models they include.
| Tier | Price/mo | API value/mo | Tokens/mo | Tasks/mo at everyday agent coding | Tasks per $ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Google AI PlusNot published as a number | $4.99 | No published meter reading · no included model reaches index 48.2Includes 3.8 Flash | |||
| Google AI ProNot published as a number | $20 | No published meter reading · cheapest at the bar: Opus 5.5 medium, $2.45/task at API priceIncludes Argon, Opus 5.5, Sonnet 5.5, 3.8 Flash | |||
| Google AI Ultra 5x"5x higher usage limits vs. AI Pro" | $100 | No published meter reading · cheapest at the bar: Opus 5.5 medium, $2.45/task at API priceIncludes Carbon, Argon, Opus 5.5, Sonnet 5.5, 3.8 Flash | |||
| Google AI Ultra 20x"20x higher usage limits vs. AI Pro" | $200 | No published meter reading · cheapest at the bar: Opus 5.5 medium, $2.45/task at API priceIncludes Carbon, Argon, Opus 5.5, Sonnet 5.5, 3.8 Flash | |||
Grok xAI
| Tier | Price/mo | API value/mo | Tokens/mo | Tasks/mo at everyday agent coding | Tasks per $ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| X PlusWeekly pool shared by Grok and Cursor | $8 | No published meter reading · no included model reaches index 48.2Includes Grok 4.7 | |||
| X Premium"4x more usage compared to Plus" | $30 | No published meter reading · no included model reaches index 48.2Includes Grok 4.7 | |||
| X Super"15x more usage compared to Plus" | $100 | No published meter reading · no included model reaches index 48.2Includes Grok 4.7 | |||
| X Ultra"50x more usage compared to Plus" | $200 | No published meter reading · no included model reaches index 48.2Includes Grok 4.7 | |||
| SuperGrok Heavyretired | $300 | $5,832Grok 4.7 | 10.3B | no included model reaches the bar | |
Which model for which job
Anthropic's guide names a starting model per job. Its benchmark score becomes the bar; each plan gets the model and effort that clears it for the most tasks.
| Job | Anthropic's pick → bar | Claude Ultra | ChatGPT Pro 200 | Google AI Ultra 20x | X Ultra |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Triage & extractionClassify, route, tag, pull fields out | Haiku 5.5 mediumindex ≥ 24.6 | Sonnet 5.5 low24,504/mo | Sol 6.1 low12,944/mo | Sonnet 5.5 low$0.51/task · unmetered | Grok 4.7 low$2.92/task · unmetered |
| Chat & quick answersInteractive sessions you wait on | Sonnet 5.5 mediumindex ≥ 30.8 | Sonnet 5.5 medium16,048/mo | Sol 6.1 low12,944/mo | Sonnet 5.5 medium$0.78/task · unmetered | Grok 4.7 low$2.92/task · unmetered |
| Scoped codingBug fixes, spec-driven features | Sonnet 5.5 highindex ≥ 41.5CursorBench 47.8% · $1.20/task | Sonnet 5.5 high7,658/mo | Sol 6.1 medium5,817/mo | Sonnet 5.5 high$1.64/task · unmetered | nothing reaches it |
| Everyday agent codingMulti-file features, debugging | Opus 5.5 mediumindex ≥ 48.2CursorBench 52.5% · $2.91/task | Opus 5.5 medium4,784/mo | Sol 6.1 high3,537/mo | Opus 5.5 medium$2.45/task · unmetered | nothing reaches it |
| Hardest problemsMigrations, architecture, research | Fable 5.2 mediumindex ≥ 56.4CursorBench 54.8% · $4.66/task | Opus 5.5 xhigh1,939/mo | Astra max459/mo | Opus 5.5 xhigh$6.05/task · unmetered | nothing reaches it |
Method
- MeterTokens a month each plan holds, read by SemiAnalysis (2026-10-05) from the providers' own usage meters. Never from a price page.
- PriceThose tokens at API list price, blended by an agentic mix: 0.43% input, 96.6% cache reads, 2.63% cache writes, 0.34% output.
- TasksAPI dollars ÷ Intelligence Index v5.0.1 cost per task at each effort. CursorBench 4.0 is the coding cross-check.
- ComparePlans at the same quality bar, at the same price. Announced but unmetered changes are shown, never counted.
Changed since the meter reading
- SemiAnalysis detected an Anthropic A/B test that cuts monthly API value by about 20% and raises the 5-hour limit by about 20% on some accounts. source
- OpenAI announced it doubled all usage limits on Pro 100, 200 and 500. No meter reading after the change has been published, so the measured figures stay; the doubling is shown only as a labelled what-if. source
- Max 5x renamed Max, Max 20x renamed Ultra, same prices; Ultra loses the 5-hour limit for verified accounts; weekly limits unchanged. Readings carry over to the renamed plans. source
- Claude Fable 5.2 replaced Fable 5.1 as the flagship. No meter reading for Fable 5.2 has been published, so Fable on Claude plans is unmeasured until one is. source
Checked against the video
The method was rebuilt from $200 for ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini? I Did the Math and run on the inputs the video used. None of its numbers is an input.
45/48
video figures reproduced with the inputs as of 2026-10-26
27/48
still the same with November 2026 inputs
Replay of the video (2026-10-26 inputs), every figure
| Figure | Video | Ours | Why | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude Max 20x API value (Opus 5.5) | $11,726 | $11,726 | same | |
| ChatGPT Pro 200 API value (Sol 6.1) | $2,084 | $2,090 | same | |
| API-value ratio at $200 | 5.60× | 5.61× | same | |
| Claude Pro API value (Opus 5.5) | $1,178 | $1,181 | same | |
| ChatGPT Plus API value (Sol 6.1) | $211 | $213 | same | |
| Claude Max 5x API value (Opus 5.5) | $5,725 | $5,739 | same | |
| ChatGPT Pro 100 API value (Sol 6.1) | $1,055 | $1,045 | same | |
| Same ratio at every tier | yes | yes | same | |
| Blended Opus 5.5 price per MTok (agentic) | $0.40 | $0.41 | same | |
| Blended Sol 6.1 price per MTok (agentic) | $0.20 | $0.20 | same | |
| Max 20x tokens a month (billions) | 29.0B | 28.6B | same | |
| Pro 200 tokens a month (billions) | 10.0B | 10.2B | same | |
| Token ratio at $200 | 2.80× | 2.80× | same | |
| Opus API value per $1 of fee | $58.90 | $59.03 | same | |
| Sol API value per $1 of fee | $10.55 | $10.66 | same | |
| No volume discount at either lab | yes | yes | same | |
| Max 20x tokens in one 5-hour window (millions) | 1,740M | 1,756M | same | |
| Max 20x tokens in one week (millions) | 6,579M | 6,584M | same | |
| Full 5-hour windows per week | 3.80× | 3.75× | same | |
| Matched-score pair | claude-opus-5.5@medium vs gpt-6.1-sol@xhigh | claude-opus-5.5@medium vs gpt-6.1-sol@xhigh | same | |
| Cost-per-task ratio at matched score | 3.40× | 3.40× | same | |
| Max 20x tasks a month (Opus medium) | 8,750 | 8,777 | same | |
| Pro 200 tasks a month (Sol xhigh) | 5,340 | 5,321 | same | |
| Max 20x tasks per working day | 400 | 399 | same | |
| Pro 200 tasks per working day | 240 | 242 | same | |
| Task ratio at matched score | 1.60× | 1.65× | same | |
| Opus 5.5 max-effort index score | 58.0 | 57.6 | same | |
| Opus max vs medium cost per task | 4.50× | 4.48× | same | |
| Max 20x tasks a month at max effort | 1,960 | 1,960 | same | |
| Pro 200 tasks a month at max effort | 2,890 | 2,887 | same | |
| At max effort ChatGPT does more tasks | yes | yes | same | |
| Max 20x Fable 5.1 API value | $2,485 | $2,506 | same | |
| Pro 200 Astra API value | $2,897 | $2,865 | same | |
| Flagship matched pair | claude-fable-5.1@xhigh vs gpt-6-astra@max | claude-fable-5.1@xhigh vs gpt-6-astra@max | same | |
| Max 20x Fable tasks a month | 416 | 419 | same | |
| Pro 200 Astra tasks a month | 889 | 879 | same | |
| Astra tasks if $2,897 were the old allowance | 444 | 440 | same | SemiAnalysis labels 1.9B as the Pro 200 allowance after the Sep 29 cut, so the halving hedge is not needed. |
| Pro 500 Astra vs old Pro 200 | 1.21× | 1.21× | same | |
| Ultrafast burn rate | 8.00× | 8.00× | same | |
| Gemini 4 Argon index score | 53.0 | 52.6 | same | |
| Gemini 4 Argon cost per task | $1.99 | $1.62 | different | Artificial Analysis changed Gemini 4 Argon's cost per task during Oct 26: the Wayback capture at 2026-10-26 01:02 UTC shows $1.99 (the video's figure), the 21:23 capture this replay uses shows $1.62. https://web.archive.org/web/20261026010237/https://artificialanalysis.ai/leaderboards/models |
| Argon API price doubles on Dec 1 | yes | yes | same | |
| Google AI Ultra has no published meter reading | yes | yes | same | |
| Max 20x Opus API value, chat mix | $9,200 | $9,203 | same | |
| Max 20x API value on the A/B-test variant | $9,385 | $9,380 | same | |
| Max 5x tasks a month (Opus medium) | 4,270 | 4,295 | same | |
| June: ChatGPT Pro ~$14,000 vs Claude Max 20x ~$8,000 | not recomputed | – | n/a | Not recomputed: needs SemiAnalysis' June readings and June models, which this run does not fetch. |
| Opus max burns the weekly allowance ~11x faster than medium | 11.00× | – | n/a | Not reproducible: Artificial Analysis publishes cost per task, not tokens per task, and cost per task gives 4.5x, not 11x. |
This month vs the video, with what moved
| Figure | Video | Ours | Why | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude Max 20x API value (Opus 5.5) | $11,726 | $11,726 | same | |
| ChatGPT Pro 200 API value (Sol 6.1) | $2,084 | $2,090 | same | |
| API-value ratio at $200 | 5.60× | 5.61× | same | |
| Claude Pro API value (Opus 5.5) | $1,178 | $1,181 | same | |
| ChatGPT Plus API value (Sol 6.1) | $211 | $213 | same | |
| Claude Max 5x API value (Opus 5.5) | $5,725 | $5,739 | same | |
| ChatGPT Pro 100 API value (Sol 6.1) | $1,055 | $1,045 | same | |
| Same ratio at every tier | yes | yes | same | |
| Blended Opus 5.5 price per MTok (agentic) | $0.40 | $0.41 | same | |
| Blended Sol 6.1 price per MTok (agentic) | $0.20 | $0.20 | same | |
| Max 20x tokens a month (billions) | 29.0B | 28.6B | same | |
| Pro 200 tokens a month (billions) | 10.0B | 10.2B | same | |
| Token ratio at $200 | 2.80× | 2.80× | same | |
| Opus API value per $1 of fee | $58.90 | $59.03 | same | |
| Sol API value per $1 of fee | $10.55 | $10.66 | same | |
| No volume discount at either lab | yes | yes | same | |
| Max 20x tokens in one 5-hour window (millions) | 1,740M | 1,756M | same | |
| Max 20x tokens in one week (millions) | 6,579M | 6,584M | same | |
| Full 5-hour windows per week | 3.80× | 3.75× | same | |
| Matched-score pair | claude-opus-5.5@medium vs gpt-6.1-sol@xhigh | claude-opus-5.5@medium vs gpt-6.1-sol@medium | different | scores [51.243, 51.038] → [48.208, 46.347]; Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| Cost-per-task ratio at matched score | 3.40× | 6.82× | different | usd_per_task [1.336, 0.3929] → [2.4511, 0.3594]; Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| Max 20x tasks a month (Opus medium) | 8,750 | 4,784 | different | usd_per_task 1.336 → 2.451; Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| Pro 200 tasks a month (Sol xhigh) | 5,340 | 5,817 | different | usd_per_task 0.3929 → 0.3594; Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| Max 20x tasks per working day | 400 | 217 | different | Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| Pro 200 tasks per working day | 240 | 264 | different | Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| Task ratio at matched score | 1.60× | 0.82× | different | Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| Opus 5.5 max-effort index score | 58.0 | 59.1 | different | Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| Opus max vs medium cost per task | 4.50× | 4.09× | different | Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| Max 20x tasks a month at max effort | 1,960 | 1,168 | different | usd_per_task 5.982 → 10.04; Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| Pro 200 tasks a month at max effort | 2,890 | 1,643 | different | usd_per_task 0.7242 → 1.272; Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| At max effort ChatGPT does more tasks | yes | yes | same | |
| Max 20x Fable 5.1 API value | $2,485 | – | n/a | Fable 5.1 left the Claude plans on 2026-11-09 (replaced by Fable 5.2) and is not in this Artificial Analysis index; no meter reading for Fable 5.2 has been published, so the flagship comparison waits for one. |
| Pro 200 Astra API value | $2,897 | $2,865 | same | |
| Flagship matched pair | claude-fable-5.1@xhigh vs gpt-6-astra@max | – | n/a | Fable 5.1 left the Claude plans on 2026-11-09 (replaced by Fable 5.2) and is not in this Artificial Analysis index; no meter reading for Fable 5.2 has been published, so the flagship comparison waits for one. |
| Max 20x Fable tasks a month | 416 | – | n/a | Fable 5.1 left the Claude plans on 2026-11-09 (replaced by Fable 5.2) and is not in this Artificial Analysis index; no meter reading for Fable 5.2 has been published, so the flagship comparison waits for one. |
| Pro 200 Astra tasks a month | 889 | – | n/a | Fable 5.1 left the Claude plans on 2026-11-09 (replaced by Fable 5.2) and is not in this Artificial Analysis index; no meter reading for Fable 5.2 has been published, so the flagship comparison waits for one. |
| Astra tasks if $2,897 were the old allowance | 444 | – | n/a | Fable 5.1 left the Claude plans on 2026-11-09 (replaced by Fable 5.2) and is not in this Artificial Analysis index; no meter reading for Fable 5.2 has been published, so the flagship comparison waits for one. |
| Pro 500 Astra vs old Pro 200 | 1.21× | 1.21× | same | |
| Ultrafast burn rate | 8.00× | 8.00× | same | |
| Gemini 4 Argon index score | 53.0 | 50.4 | different | Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| Gemini 4 Argon cost per task | $1.99 | $9.95 | different | Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| Argon API price doubles on Dec 1 | yes | yes | same | |
| Google AI Ultra has no published meter reading | yes | yes | same | |
| Max 20x Opus API value, chat mix | $9,200 | $9,203 | same | |
| Max 20x API value on the A/B-test variant | $9,385 | $9,380 | same | |
| Max 5x tasks a month (Opus medium) | 4,270 | 2,341 | different | usd_per_task 1.336 → 2.451; Artificial Analysis re-indexed (Intelligence Index v4.3.2 → Intelligence Index v5.0.1) |
| June: ChatGPT Pro ~$14,000 vs Claude Max 20x ~$8,000 | not recomputed | – | n/a | Not recomputed: needs SemiAnalysis' June readings and June models, which this run does not fetch. |
| Opus max burns the weekly allowance ~11x faster than medium | 11.00× | – | n/a | Not reproducible: Artificial Analysis publishes cost per task, not tokens per task, and cost per task gives 4.5x, not 11x. |
Sources
- Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index Intelligence Index v5.0.1
- CursorBench 4.0
- API prices (Claude)
- API prices (GPT-6)
- API prices (Gemini)
- API prices (Grok)
- Plan prices
- Plan prices
- Plan prices
- Plan prices
- Usage meters: SemiAnalysis, 2026-10-05
- Which Claude model should you build with?
- Change 2026-10-22
- Change 2026-10-29
- Change 2026-10-30
- Change 2026-11-09